Sugarcreek, OH Airbnb Market Data, Statistics, and Occupancy Rates

Sugarcreek Short-Term Rental Market Overview

Sugarcreek, OH — known for its Amish Country charm and steady tourism appeal — offers a competitive short-term rental landscape with 59 active Airbnb listings and an average annual revenue of $34,112. With an ADR of $221 (below Ohio's $250 state average) and occupancy sitting at 29%, the market rewards investors who can differentiate through property quality and strategic pricing. A 129% year-over-year increase in active listings signals strong investor interest, though it also means deal sourcing needs to be more selective to maintain margins.

Key Market Statistics

According to Rabbu market data, the Sugarcreek short-term rental market shows:

Data sources: Rabbu proprietary analytics as of Apr, 27 2026 and Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI) as of Mar, 17 2026.

Why Investors Consider Sugarcreek

Investors are drawn to Sugarcreek for its tourism-driven demand rooted in Amish Country experiences, though the market's competitive dynamics require careful property selection and pricing strategy.

Expert Market Assessment

"Sugarcreek earns a 'Competitive Opportunity' designation, reflecting genuine investor interest tempered by a below-average revenue-to-price ratio and increasing supply. The market's pronounced seasonality — with July revenue ($4,730) running more than four times January's ($1,164) — means cash-flow planning around off-peak months is critical. Larger properties consistently outperform on both ADR and RevPAN, suggesting that investors willing to acquire 3- or 4-bedroom units can capture stronger returns even at lower occupancy rates. The above-average occupancy stability is a meaningful bright spot, indicating that while fill rates are modest, they tend to hold relatively steady rather than swinging wildly."

— Rabbu Market Analysis Team

Key Airbnb Metrics & Trends in Sugarcreek

Average revenue by month in Sugarcreek

Revenue in Sugarcreek follows a strong seasonal curve, peaking in July at $4,730 and bottoming out in January at just $1,164 — a spread of over 4x. A secondary fall peak in October ($3,759) reflects the area's autumn tourism draw, giving investors two distinct high-earning windows to maximize pricing.

Active Airbnb listings by property size in Sugarcreek

Two-bedroom properties dominate Sugarcreek's supply with 19 listings, followed by 1-bedrooms (15) and 3-bedrooms (13), while 4-bedroom units are the scarcest at just 7 listings. The limited supply of larger homes relative to their revenue performance may represent an opportunity for investors willing to acquire bigger properties in an underserved segment.

Average daily rate (ADR) by property size in Sugarcreek

ADR in Sugarcreek scales consistently with size, jumping from $158 for 1-bedroom units to $303 for 4-bedroom properties — nearly doubling the nightly rate. The steepest relative premium appears between 3-bedrooms ($249) and 4-bedrooms ($303), suggesting groups and families are willing to pay meaningfully more for extra space.

Average RevPAN by property size in Sugarcreek

RevPAN climbs steadily with property size, from $45 for 1-bedroom units to $77 for 4-bedrooms, confirming that larger properties generate more revenue per available night even after accounting for their lower occupancy rates. The gap between 2-bedrooms ($64) and 3-bedrooms ($67) is narrow, indicating 3-bedroom units may offer better value given their higher ADR upside.

Average occupancy rates by property size in Sugarcreek

Occupancy rates are relatively compressed across property sizes, ranging from 25% for 4-bedroom units to 31% for 2-bedrooms. While smaller units fill slightly more often, the modest 6-percentage-point spread means occupancy differences alone don't dramatically shift cash-flow dynamics — ADR and RevPAN are the bigger differentiators.

Average monthly revenue by property size in Sugarcreek

Four-bedroom properties lead monthly revenue at $4,308, nearly doubling the $2,039 earned by 1-bedroom units. The jump from 2-bedrooms ($2,196) to 3-bedrooms ($3,388) is the most significant step up, suggesting that crossing the 3-bedroom threshold unlocks meaningfully stronger earning potential.

Average annual revenue by property size in Sugarcreek

Annual revenue ranges from $24,469 for 1-bedroom properties to $51,701 for 4-bedroom homes, with 4-bedrooms generating more than twice the income of the smallest units. Investors targeting the highest absolute returns should focus on 3- and 4-bedroom configurations, which earn $40,661 and $51,701 respectively, though acquisition costs and financing terms will ultimately determine net ROI.

Most common amenities for Airbnb listings in Sugarcreek

Parking (98%) and kitchen access (97%) are near-universal in Sugarcreek listings, reflecting the car-dependent, self-catering nature of Amish Country tourism. Outdoor amenities like patios (81%), outdoor furniture (76%), and BBQ grills (73%) are also prevalent, setting a high baseline — investors looking to stand out should consider differentiators like hot tubs (only 22% of listings) or pet-friendly policies (14%).

Understanding Sugarcreek's ROI Score: 54/100

Rabbu's ROI Score is a proprietary metric that evaluates short-term rental investment potential based on multiple factors.

How the ROI Score is Calculated

What This Means for Investors

Sugarcreek's ROI Score of 54 out of 100 places it in the 'Competitive Opportunity' band, signaling that while demand is real, returns aren't automatic. The below-average revenue-to-price ratio is the primary headwind — average home values of $653,168 against $34,112 in annual revenue make underwriting tight — though above-average occupancy stability provides some reassurance on cash-flow consistency. Investors should pair this data with thorough local regulatory research and focus on larger properties where RevPAN and total revenue meaningfully outperform the market average.

Short-Term Rental Regulations in Sugarcreek

Understanding local STR regulations is essential before investing in Sugarcreek. Here's the current regulatory landscape:

Permit Requirements

Sugarcreek, Ohio may require short-term rental operators to obtain a local business registration or permit before listing their property. Investors should verify current permit requirements directly with the Village of Sugarcreek and Tuscarawas County, as regulations in smaller Ohio municipalities can change with limited public notice.

Key Restrictions

Common restrictions that may apply include occupancy limits tied to bedroom count, noise ordinances, parking requirements for rural and village properties, and potential HOA covenants in planned communities. Some Ohio jurisdictions also impose minimum-stay requirements or cap the total number of STR permits issued in a given area, so confirming these details before closing on a property is essential.

Tax Obligations

Ohio requires short-term rental operators to collect and remit state sales tax and county lodging taxes, and Tuscarawas County may impose additional transient occupancy assessments. Many booking platforms like Airbnb handle a portion of tax collection automatically, but hosts should confirm all obligations with the Ohio Department of Taxation to ensure full compliance.

Regulations subject to change. Always verify with local authorities before purchasing. A Rabbu partner agent specializing in Sugarcreek can provide current regulatory guidance.

Future Outlook & Long-Term Forecast

"Over the next 12–18 months, Sugarcreek's seasonal tourism cycle — anchored by summer and fall peaks — should continue to drive predictable demand patterns. Occupancy rates may remain in the 27–32% range as new supply absorbs into the market, though ADR could see modest upward pressure of 2–4% if operators invest in amenities that match rising guest expectations. The rapid growth in listings suggests the market is transitioning from emerging to competitive, so investors entering now should factor in tighter margins and longer stabilization periods. Seasonal revenue swings of nearly 4x between January and July underscore the importance of budgeting for slower winter months."

— Rabbu Market Analysis Team

Frequently asked questions about Airbnb in Sugarcreek, OH

What is the average Airbnb occupancy rate in Sugarcreek?

The average occupancy rate for Airbnb listings in Sugarcreek is currently 29%, which falls below Ohio's state average of 34%. Occupancy varies by property size, with 2-bedroom units performing best at 31% and 4-bedroom properties averaging 25%. While these rates are modest, the market shows above-average occupancy stability, meaning fill rates tend to remain consistent rather than fluctuating unpredictably.

How much do Airbnb hosts make in Sugarcreek?

Airbnb hosts in Sugarcreek earn an average of $2,842 per month and approximately $34,112 per year based on trailing 12-month booking data. Revenue varies significantly by property size — 1-bedroom units average around $24,469 annually, while 4-bedroom properties bring in roughly $51,701. Seasonal demand also plays a major role, with summer months generating two to four times the revenue of winter.

Is Sugarcreek a good market for Airbnb investment?

Sugarcreek scores a 54 out of 100 on Rabbu's ROI Score, placing it in the 'Competitive Opportunity' category. The market benefits from steady Amish Country tourism and above-average occupancy stability, but faces challenges from a below-average revenue-to-price ratio given the $653,168 average home value against $34,112 in annual revenue. Investors who target larger properties and differentiate through quality amenities are best positioned to succeed here.

What is the average daily rate (ADR) for Airbnb in Sugarcreek?

The average daily rate across all Sugarcreek Airbnb listings is $221, coming in below the Ohio state average of $250. ADR scales meaningfully with property size: 1-bedroom units average $158 per night, while 4-bedroom properties command $303. This pricing gradient suggests that guests visiting the area are willing to pay a premium for larger, group-friendly accommodations.

Are short-term rentals legal in Sugarcreek?

Short-term rentals are generally permitted in Sugarcreek, Ohio, though operators may need to obtain local permits or business registrations. Regulations can vary at the village and county level, so prospective hosts should verify current requirements with the Village of Sugarcreek and Tuscarawas County before listing. Ohio state sales tax and applicable county lodging taxes must also be collected and remitted.

When is peak season for Airbnb in Sugarcreek?

Peak season in Sugarcreek runs from June through October, with July topping out at $4,730 in average monthly revenue and October close behind at $3,759. The fall surge aligns with the area's popular autumn foliage and Amish Country harvest events. January is the softest month at $1,164, making winter cash-flow planning important for investors.

How many Airbnbs are there in Sugarcreek?

There are currently 59 active Airbnb listings in Sugarcreek as of April 2026. The supply is distributed across property sizes, with 2-bedroom units being most common (19 listings) followed by 1-bedroom (15), 3-bedroom (13), and 4-bedroom (7). Notably, active listings have grown 129% year-over-year, reflecting significant new investor interest in the market.

How is Airbnb revenue calculated in Sugarcreek?

The annual and monthly revenue figures shown for Sugarcreek are derived from the trailing 12 months of historical booking performance for active comparable Airbnb listings in the market — they are not forward-looking projections. Rabbu averages each comparable listing's actual revenue per available night (RevPAN) by month over the past year, removes regional outliers, and rolls the remainder into a market-level historical average. This approach anchors the figures to what hosts have actually earned recently while naturally reflecting seasonal peaks and slower months, since each month uses its own historical performance data. Individual results can vary based on property quality, pricing strategy, and operational management.

About Rabbu Market Data

Rabbu provides Airbnb and short-term rental market data and statistics across the United States. Our mission is to empower investors with accurate insights and easy-to-use tools, so they can confidently identify and act on the best opportunities in the Airbnb market.

What this data includes

• Regularly updated active Airbnb and STR listing counts by market and property size
• Occupancy, ADR, and RevPAN trends across bedroom configurations
• Monthly and annual revenue metrics based on trailing 12-month booking data
• Home value benchmarks sourced from the Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI)
• Supply growth and year-over-year listing trends for competitive analysis

Sources and disclaimers

Rabbu proprietary analytics as of Apr, 27 2026 and Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI) as of Mar, 17 2026. Revenue projections are estimates based on comparable properties and do not guarantee future performance. Data reflects trailing 12-month averages and may not capture very recent market shifts or regulatory changes. Individual property results will vary based on location, condition, pricing strategy, and management quality.